Anatomy of a Conflict
Anatomy of a Conflict
Identity, Knowledge, and Emotion in Old-Growth Forests
Anatomy of a Conflict explores the cultural aspects of the fierce dispute between activist loggers and environmentalists over the fate of Oregon’s temperate rain forest. Centred on the practice of old-growth logging and the survival of the northern spotted owl, the conflict has lead to the burning down of ranger stations, the spiking of trees, logging truck blockades, and countless demonstrations and arrests.
Satterfield shows how the debate about the forest is, at its core, a debate about the cultural make-up of the Pacific Northwest. To talk about forests is to talk about culture, whether the discussion is about scientific explanations of conifer forests, activists’ grassroots status and their emotional attachment to land, or the implications of past people’s land use for future forest management. An engaging ethnographic study, this book emphasizes the historical roots and contemporary emergence of identity movements as a means for challenging cultural patterns. It makes a significant contribution to culture- and identity-driven theories of human action in the context of social movements and environmental studies.
Awards
- 2002, Winner - K.D. Srivastava Award, UBC Press
This is an excellent work, and is essential reading for those engaged in the sociology of natural resources (a term contested by some), and perhaps for environmental sociologists more broadly. As someone who has a cross-appointment in a Faculty of Forestry, I think this should be required reading for students of forestry. However, I think it should also have broader appeal beyond the academy, to those citizens who are interested in the conflict over old-growth forests.
An excellent piece of ethnographic analysis of value not only to scholars interested in environmental issues but to those working in the wider field of human ecology and in related areas of identity, political process, emotion, science, and the general construction of cultural conventions.
This book makes a significant contribution to our understanding of environmental controversies. While economic and political dimensions of forest controversies have been closely studied, the anthropological perspective provided by this book is novel, and important.
Acknowledgments
Notes on Names and Methods
Illustrations
1 Introduction: A Cultural Dialogue about Old-Growth Forests
2 The Cycle of History: Public Lands, Forest Health, and Activist Histories in the American West
3 Disturbances in the Field and the Defining of Social Movements
4 Negotiating Agency in the Quest for Grassroots Legitimacy
5 Voodoo Science and Common Sense
6 Theorizing Culture: Defining the Past and Imagining the Possible
7 Irrational Actors: Emotions, Ethics, and the Ecocentred Self
8 Concluding Discussion: The Triangular Shape of Cultural Production
Notes
References
Index
